I feel sad and unsettled tonight.
I was sitting here at the computer reading blogs and eating a can of white asparagus (exciting, balanced dinner, no?) when this wave of...whatever...hit me. I very nearly started to cry, something I've not done outside of an airport for quite some time now.
September 11th came and went, and I didn't even reflect adequately on the significance of the anniversary. I just went about my day, realizing that it was a somber one only when I needed to go to the US embassy to get a statement saying that I have a clean criminal record (visa processing requirement) and found the consular section closed in observance of the events 6 years ago.
I sat and thought about it for a moment, remembering where I was when the planes hit, feeling the weight of where we've come since then, and feeling generally numb.
I feel very detached sometimes, from family, from "home" (that ever-elusive concept), from friends that I've left behind, from the US and all of its influence on me as an individual and on the world at large.
I am ambivalent about politics at home, yet sense in my bones and breath the importance of the official war reports and campaign tactics being presented at the moment. And still I feel disconnected, apathetic. As if no matter which direction we go, the final result will be the same. I wish I were more passionate. I wish I could bring myself to read or watch the news on a daily basis. I'm aware that ignorance and my current stalled state of mind don't help the situation at all, but I also can't pretend to feel any other way at the moment.
People here often ask my views on politics, on what it means to be an American expat; they wonder whether Ricardo and I will live in the States at any point, and ask why I left in the first place. People want to know why I often appear Brazilian on the outside. Why my language, style and mannerisms seem to project something so different than is expected of an American.
I have no good answers, even when I ask the same questions of myself.
I simply know quietly, intuitively, that certain things I believe in and certain others I don't. I know when a path feels right, or when a decision is so wrong that I am afraid I will be physically ill. These things I know on a corporal level, yet for all the analyzing I do in other aspects of my life, for all of the writing about emotions and processing of feelings I do, I can't seem to form rational, accessible explanations that would allow others to understand.
I feel very lonely most of the time. Some of this is my own "fault", I suppose, for once you step out of your home city, once you board that plane, once you acquire a new perspective that is different enough from the things you originally were taught and believed in, it is impossible to go back. Physically, of course, one can always return to a hometown or an old group of friends, but always with the sharp realization that relationships have changed forever.
For a long time I struggled with an identity crisis. I was very ashamed to be American, and this contributed to my feelings of isolation, both in the US and out. When at home, I recognized that I had changed in my time abroad and that I no longer related to my friends - and even my family, in some respects - in the same comfortable way as before.
When I was in Brazil, or in Italy, or wherever on my travels inbetween, I had to deal with the fact that I also didn't fit in with my new peers, and that worse yet, I was known for being "the American". At the high school I attended in Southern Brazil, many friends playfully nicknamed me "gringa". I pretended not to care, but each time I heard the name (which is used to refer to all foreign people in Brazil, not just Americans) I cringed, as it reminded me of the identity and background with which I felt so ill at ease.
It took literally nearly a decade, but now I am over this crisis for the most part, at least in the sense that I am no longer ashamed to say that I am American and speak English in public (yes, it was that bad at one point when I was a teenager).
I still feel strange about many aspects of being an American, but it is more in the sense that I identify more with a culture to which I have no "legitimate" claims than with the one in which I was raised.
Once an ex-boyfriend of mine commented that I was destined to be lonely and unfulfilled my entire life because I was in love with a country, something that could never love me back.
That made me laugh, but it also made me sad. Not because I expected to have Brazil fill some sort of hole in my heart, but because I realized that likely nobody would ever understand how that country affected my life. I still very much feel this way.
So, sitting here in our flat in Maputo, contemplating culture and identity and the role my home country has in the world, I feel quite alone.
Perhaps this is why I like cats so much - they always "get" me, no words or passports required...
11 comments:
Oi Ali,
Long-time lurker, first-time poster here: I'm just a random stranger reading your blog (que otimo, by the way!), but I felt that what you wrote today really resonated with me. A little backstory: I lived in Brazil in Manaus for a while with my (now ex-)boyfriend a couple years ago. What you wrote really relates, especially these parts:
"...I was destined to be lonely and unfulfilled my entire life because I was in love with a country, something that could never love me back."
Hmm, has your ex-boyfriend ever stood in the middle of Amazonia or the Mata Atlantica listening to the birds and other life going on? To me, that feels a lot like love in that it is simultaneously very comforting and invigorating/inspiring.
"That ...also made me sad...because I realized that likely nobody would ever understand how that country affected my life. I still very much feel this way."
Well, it probably doesn't mean much, but I totally know how you feel. I haven't been back to Brazil in a year and people still ask me why I'm always so obsessed with Brazil. I tell them that if they went down there, they'd understand. :)
"Perhaps this is why I like cats so much - they always "get" me, no words or passports required..."
EXACTLY. Cats totally "get" us. That's why I love them, too.
Desculpe por falando muiiito :)
Tracy
Oy, Ali! Your ex-boyfriend was quite wrong. Brazil does love you back! And that is why you feel so close to it. And you're being so hugged right now too!I think that our place in the world is not necessarily where we were born. That is such a silly concept! There is a reason why we go places and drink in all those experiences... I totally relate to this post and I have struggled with this duality as well. But guess what? I mean it in the other direction :-) from tupiniquin to american...
xo
(hugs to you too, Tracy!)
Have you ever checked out the writings of Krishnamurti at: http://tchl.freeweb.hu/ ?
He was the master at seeing through culture and self-preoccupations and self-limiting cultural identities, and the book I particularly recommend is Think on These Things, which was originally published as This Matter of Culture. He was the most influential thinker of the 20th century and claimed as the teacher of virtually every other great teacher of this era in every field of human interest and activity. "Think" is the model of clarity in thinking for any purpose, as he could see through every limitation of thought or culture.
Your quandary seems to be of this matter of cultural identity and how you resolve it: you see right through it and beyond. Unlike many people, you’ve experienced many different cultures and cultural identities which requires you to eventually integrate them all into a greater One -- instead of maintaining the many fragmented and even self-contradictory many.
That’s one of the rites of passage once you get out of school and have kicked around at a few jobs and interests -- preparatory to developing the confidence and dedication required to put your all into the one. You seem to frequently be wracked by highs and lows -- which you need to learn to feel comfortable with and ride out into it exhausts itself and heads in another direction, but then you know the limits of those parameters -- rather than the self-limiting ones of fearing to find out.eceiup
The post raises a thousand questions... I keep thinking.. there's something missing in the story.
You're young still, things fall into place later. I have learned to embrace and own all cultures I have been a part of. And, I have become my own best friend, which comes in really handy in moments of loyalty struggles. The ache of missing a country and all it represents is at times unbearable... I know..
~Tracy - Que bom que você comentou! It's always so nice to discover someone with whom I seen to have a lot in common has been reading my blog. I imagine that you do relate quite a bit to the attachment I feel to Brazil, and to the influence the country has had on my life.
I liked what you said about the mata atlântica and nature. Some of my very dearest and most saudades-inducing memories of Brazil are of looking out bus windows at the landscape of Maranhão or Paraná, watching the world go by.
Boa sorte com tudo, e espero que fales aqui mais vezes. Beijos!!
~Alex - I agree that one's birthplace doesn't necessarily represent one's identity or allegiance. And I'm not at all surprised that you have the same experience as me, only reversed. From your writing it is quite obvious, and it will only increase, I imagine, with your upcoming marriage and the challenge of raising multi-cultural kids (if family is something you think about having)...I will have the same challenges, too, seeing as I'm set to marry a carioca!
~Mike - Thank you for the book recommendation. I will add it to my list of Amazon purchases for the end of the year.
The observation you made about my ups and downs is spot on. I think the roller-coaster effect has been one of the defining characteristics of the last several years of my life, in particular here in Mozambique. In talking with friends here, it seems I am definitely not unique in feeling such drastic swings in mood and perspective. I am trying to be accepting of these emotional extremes, feel them for what they are, etc. but it is obviously difficult.
You expressed quite well the idea of a cultural identity that is a greater One. This is what I was searching to say in my post at several points.
~Shades of Blue - I take comfort in the idea that this struggle to reconcile various cultures and countries into one's unique identity becomes easier as time goes on. I also am a total believer in the "you must be your own best friend" concept! Thanks for your support. :)
It's a fairly typical writer's/artist's personality/profile, which led Abraham Maslow, the researcher on human actualization, to pronounce that he had never encountered a well-adjusted, highly-actualized writer.
Up to the last century, the revered writer was invariably drug or alcohol induced, with frequent great swings of mood -- making them manic at their most creative and also extremely depressed at other times, often leading to taking their own lives.
Usually when one is in the "funk," there is this tendency to fight it -- which actually gives it more energy and power, rather than accepting these cycles as everybody also has although not as severely. Once you can accept the normality of such events, you can learn how to make them your friend and harness them.
A lot of people place tremendous demands on themselves, asking, "Why am I not creative and brilliant all the time as I should be?"
That's why I recommend an immediate exposure to the mind of Krishnamurti, because contrary to your expectations (or just anybody else's), he blew everybody away just in being himself -- and for that, he was the master, and what everybody fundamentally wishes to be -- the master of themselves.
You can go to the site and download any extent work of his -- which is probably the most prolific ever recorded. You don't have to read a whole book to get his message: one paragraph anywhere will provide that clarity, because he's not about thoughts in the traditional way of memory, thought and knowledge.
His concept is this much more powerful practice of "awareness" -- which allows the total intelligence and consciousness to be One (not divided by yours and mine and all the other subdivisions and fragmentations of knowledge and authorities (experts).
In this way, one can read life directly, rather than through the words, thoughts and limitations of any other. The Great Ones have been that way but in contemporary education, that is not how one is thought to know the world -- but through the intermediaries of the media, schools, universities and other self-proclaimed experts.
This is the battle on the frontlines of culture everywhere today. This is not the usual Republican-Democrat, liberal-conserrvative, right-left, American versus the world, which they would be happy for you to be distracted onto -- draining your focus with those counterproductive struggles, in which everybody nullifies everybody else.
But those who are clear and don't get caught up in all those suggestions and entertainments, is the revolution in the world -- the cutting edge where you want to be.
Ali, don't you worry. This wave of negative energies came with the bloody Tsunami. The actual waves didn't hit but the winds brought some terrible things into this city.
Everyone is either sick or sad, or having relationship problems... Um fim-de-semana de merda!!
Beijão, Ali!! Escrevi inglês pro seu publico entender. Vc eu sei que entende. Até melhor q eu! hehehe
I can't see how living in other places wouldn't change you and make you feel different about America. Or whatever country a person is from, not just America. You just see the world in another way. You are simply a world citizen, my friend.
I am happy to hear you are not ashamed of America, though. I have had enough of the self-hatred of some Americans. It is just old and mostly ignorant, imo. Nobody, and no place is perfect.
And I don't think you are alone in being able to work up passion for the workings of our government. I live here, and I can hardly stand to listen. I feel like my passion has been beaten out of me by bi-partisan bullshit for too long. I know I need to care more.
oxox :)
I understand.
Brazil is a special case. She doesn't love back...she just teaches us saudades...
~Mike - I'll definitely check out the site, though I also plan to order some books. Something about the online format - even when it is a printed page - isn't as appealing to me. :) I definitely have my work cut out for me. I'll let you know what I think of the first things I read.
~Luís - Que bom que não fui a única a ficar na depressão este fim-de-semana! Not that I'm glad other people were also feeling strange, but misery does love company... I'm glad you decided to comment!
~Amber - No, I'm DEFINITELY not ashamed to be American anymore. I struggle with how being American fits into my identity, now that I have been influenced by other people and places, but I am definitely happy to be from the place I am originally. And yeah, I hear you on the bipartisan bit. That's what I'm registered independent!
~Jenna - I know you understand! The saudades are killer...
Post a Comment